The Carolinian is a historical novel set in South Carolina in the early days the American Revolution.
Rafael Sabatini’s novel fails as a romance—its loving couple don’t trust each other an inch—but a supporting plot almost makes up for the book’s predictable and silly love story.
The Carolinian by Rafael Sabatini
Grosset & Dunlap, 1924, 414 pp. 1925 bestseller # 9. My grade: C.
As the novel opens, Harry Latimer’s fiance, Myrtle Carey, has returned his ring upon learning he’s joined the Sons of Liberty.
Harry suspects fortune-hunting, English army officer Capt. Mandeville has inserted a spy into the rebel cell.
That’s the only time in the novel, Harry gets something right: Harry has the psychological perceptivity of a hedgehog, and Myrtle is his soul-mate.
The novel’s real interest is lawyer John Rutledge.
Carolinians select Rutledge to lead them in the defense of Charles Town and the fight for independence from the Crown, despite his tendency to be somewhat imperial himself.
Fearing the town’s residents will be slaughtered by overwhelming odds, Rutledge initiates negotiations for surrender.
While passions flare around him, Rutledge scribbles away with a pencil, oblivious to everything but the document on which he’s working.
Although the Rutledge incident didn’t happen the way Sabatini tells it, it should have: It’s far more exciting than Harry and Myrtle.
© 2015 Linda Gorton Aragoni